Wednesday, October 15: Portis Somehow More Valuable Than Offensively Adept?

Photo by Ned Dishman.

Photo by Ned Dishman.

I was reading Bucky Brooks’s column over at this morning, in which he tags Kurt Warner as a frontrunner for NFL MVP. Nothing too earthshaking as far as these types of articles go; he makes a reasonably solid argument for Warner based on the stats so far this year, and then he lists out his current rankings for MVP and Offensive Player of the Year. Here are the lists, including Brooks’s commentary.


1. Trent Edwards, QB, Bills (Last week’s ranking: 5): The Bills’ budding superstar has rallied the team in three of their four victories. With a looming showdown with the Chargers, the Bills need Edwards to pick up where he left off prior to his concussion.

2. Clinton Portis, RB, Redskins (3): The league’s leading rusher has topped the century mark in three consecutive games. His re-emergence as a premiere back has ignited the Redskins’ surprisingly hot start.

3. Jay Cutler, QB, Broncos (1): The Broncos star quarterback has cooled off in recent weeks, but his solid play under center is the primary reason the team leads the AFC West.

4. Drew Brees, QB, Saints (NR): After passing for more than 300 yards for the fifth time in six starts, Brees is on track to surpass Dan Marino’s single-season passing record of 5,084 yards.

5. Kurt Warner, QB, Cardinals (NR)

Offensive Player of the Year

1. Drew Brees, QB, Saints (1)

2. Kurt Warner, QB, Cardinals (2)

3. Philip Rivers, QB, Chargers (NR): The brash signal caller has passed for three touchdowns in four games and leads the league with a 109.1 passer rating.

4. Ronnie Brown, RB, Dolphins (3): The versatile playmaker didn’t play a starring role in the team’s “Wildcat” package, but he scored for the fourth consecutive week and finished with 93 yards total offense.

5. Clinton Portis, RB, Redskins (NR)

Now, I’m easily confused by math, but I honestly don’t understand any of this. It caught my attention because of Portis, but let’s look at Drew Brees. He’s the quarterback of the New Orleans Saints. He’s having a heck of a season, driving their offense and putting points on the board. It makes perfect sense that he’d be shortlisted for Offensive POY. Meanwhile, the New Orleans defense is currently ranked 19th in yardage allowed and 20th in points allowed. So it seems unlikely that there’s someone on their defense who is more valuable to their team than Brees is. How, then, is he ranked fourth for MVP, but first for POY?

The same essential question applied for Kurt Warner, and in reverse for Portis. Clinton is having a great offensive season, absolutely, but I think it’s hard to point at one guy on the Redskins and declare them the most valuable. The defense has been doing a terrific job, Jason Campbell still hasn’t thrown an interception, the offensive line has been opening holes for Clinton … you get the idea. So why is he ranked higher in the Most Valuable category than he is in the Offensive one? This genuinely baffles me, and I’d love to hear people’s suggestions.

Either way, though, while you can’t vote for either of these awards, do remember that Pro Bowl voting is open, so be sure to do that. Frequently.


7 Responses

  1. Im confused!! thanks matt

  2. Matt, I agree completely with your comments. Bucky Brooks has rounded up the right names. But the way that he ranks them is mystifying.

    Besides, I thought that Portis never stopped being “premiere” and so could not “re-emerge” as such.

    Good job Matt Terl.

  3. There will be no confusion if you think of MVP as being the player most valuable to his team’s success. So while Drew Brees is putting up impressive offensive numbers, Edwards, Portis and Cutler are more valuable to their respective teams.

  4. Thanks for posting the article, was certainly a great read!

  5. Matt i don’t understand your comments about Drew Brees. It makes sense that he is the number one candidate for offensive player of the year because he is putting up huge numbers, and is on pace to break Dan Marinos single season passing yards record, but he is not doing what MVP’s in the NFL do and that’s win football games for his team thus far. As far as no one being as valuable on their defense, yeah that’s obvious, but were not talking about the MVP of a single team it’s across the entire league.

    I also want to throw out there that the words MVP and the name Trent Edwards, wont be in the same sentence, or thought at the end of this season. That’s an absolute joke the front runner for league MVP is a guy that is just asked to manage a game for them. His job is to not screw up.

  6. nick you’re right, it’s like naming Gus Frerrote a MVP candidate just for not screwing a Vikings game, like Tarvaris Jackson used to do.

  7. Here are my Top Five MVP Candidates Designed to Get People to Talk About My Column:

    — Trent Edwards
    — Terrell Owens
    — Clinton Portis
    — Tom Brady
    — Skip Bayless

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: